Bay Street Theatre - Eustis FL Haunted Place

Recently Shared Experiences & Comments

• 

  Haunted but not negative

  Not sure why others are saying they had negative experiences here. I’ve been told by a long time employee that they believe it is haunted but that the spirits are good and have never caused any harm. Knocking things over is about as harmful as he has ever seen or heard. This theater has not been investigated much at all. A group has come through and there is a YouTube video but it’s kind of lame and too many people in at once. My daughter performs and works here and is alone A LOT. She has never had an experience but does feel weird there but comfortable knowing they aren’t bad spirits. There is more history to the building than shared online. There was once an icecream shop to the right that burned down. In the cocktail room you can still see the burn marks of the barstools that once sat at the counter. The original ceiling above them shows damage also. No one was killed in the fire though. There are like 14 rooms to this location and a bullet hole is still left in a room upstairs from an apparent murder but I have not been able to find anything online from years past about a shooting there. No suspicious stories seem to be recorded of deaths in the theater BUT there are apartments surrounding it so who knows. We do have one cool video my daughter took that I personally noticed orbs in. She was walking down what performers refer to as the stairs of death ( a really skinny staircase for performers to travel through) and as she is walking down it clearly shows one orb jump up from a step and move to the right and then another on another step below does the same. It seems as if maybe two spirits were sitting on the steps near each other and both jumped up to move out of her way for her to pass through! It’s really neat! She didn’t feel or notice anything odd at that moment. I believe she still has that video to share. I am currently working on presenting to the board the opportunity for paranormal investigations there to bring in funds to help the theater with donations :) Just need to investigate enough prior to make sure it is truly haunted and worth investigating for outsiders.

  Posted 6/4/24

  Was this review helpful? YES NO

• 

  this place is legit

  every friday i drop my brother of to this little small town theater aka this one i never felt like it was haunted but once someone informed me it was ive been intrested of meeting a ghost there by the name of sam which my brother and his friend met during an evp in the boys dressing room which is the new hot spot of the stage my brother says about his theater. first day of first show his friend never knew i told him then we asked the ghost off the evp and we got scary answers and was attacked once

  Posted 8/5/19

  Was this review helpful? YES NO

  1 out of 2 found this review helpful

• 

  scary af

  me and my brother brought evp's where the hole is i felt very very very cold it was.....just strange i met a ghost name marry she did't seam to happy with me and scratch me and threw something at me and heard a really really low faint voice say leave and ever since i get chills and weird vibes every time i go to drop my brother off i think it is marry but it could be worse than her.....

  Posted 10/3/17

  Was this review helpful? YES NO

  2 out of 3 found this review helpful